A direct comparison of Primary Antioxidant 1790 against other leading hindered phenol antioxidants for broad industrial use
A Direct Comparison of Primary Antioxidant 1790 Against Other Leading Hindered Phenol Antioxidants for Broad Industrial Use
When it comes to antioxidants in industrial applications, the term “preservative” might not immediately spring to mind — unless you’re someone who spends their days elbow-deep in polymer formulations or rubber processing. But make no mistake: antioxidants are the unsung heroes that keep our plastics from turning brittle, our rubber from cracking under stress, and our coatings from fading under UV assault.
Among the many antioxidants on the market, hindered phenolic antioxidants hold a special place due to their robust performance across a wide range of materials. One such contender is Primary Antioxidant 1790, a compound that has steadily gained attention in recent years for its versatility and effectiveness. But how does it truly stack up against other industry leaders like Irganox 1010, Irganox 1076, and Ethanox 330?
In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into the world of hindered phenolic antioxidants, compare them head-to-head with Primary Antioxidant 1790, and explore why certain choices might be better suited for specific applications. Think of this as your guide through the antioxidant jungle — where every molecule matters and every decision can affect the longevity of your product.
What Are Hindered Phenolic Antioxidants?
Before we get into the specifics of Primary Antioxidant 1790 and its competitors, let’s set the stage by understanding what makes hindered phenolic antioxidants so valuable.
These compounds work by scavenging free radicals — unstable molecules that wreak havoc on polymers during thermal processing or exposure to oxygen. By neutralizing these radicals, hindered phenols help extend the life of materials, improve color stability, and reduce degradation.
They’re especially effective in polyolefins, engineering plastics, adhesives, and even food packaging (yes, even your yogurt cup owes some thanks to antioxidants!).
Why “Hindered”?
The term "hindered" refers to the steric bulk around the phenolic hydroxyl group. This bulky structure prevents the antioxidant from reacting too quickly, giving it a longer-lasting effect. It’s like putting armor around the active site — making it more stable and less prone to volatilization or migration out of the material.
Meet Primary Antioxidant 1790
Let’s start with the star of our show — Primary Antioxidant 1790.
This compound belongs to the family of pentaerythritol tetrakis(3-(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)propionate) — which is quite a mouthful. Let’s just call it PEPQ for short (though technically, that’s another compound; but you get the idea). Its molecular structure features four phenolic rings tethered to a central core, giving it multiple reactive sites to intercept free radicals.
Here are some of its key characteristics:
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| Molecular Formula | C₇₃H₁₀₈O₆S₂ |
| Molecular Weight | ~1250 g/mol |
| Melting Point | 55–65°C |
| Color | White to off-white powder |
| Solubility in Water | Insoluble |
| Typical Usage Level | 0.1–1.0 phr (parts per hundred resin) |
| Thermal Stability | Up to 300°C |
One of the standout features of Primary Antioxidant 1790 is its low volatility and good compatibility with a variety of resins. It also shows minimal tendency to bloom or migrate, which is crucial for long-term performance in products like automotive parts, electrical insulation, and outdoor equipment.
But how does it compare with the big names in the game?
The Competitors: Irganox 1010, Irganox 1076, and Ethanox 330
Let’s now introduce the main players in the hindered phenol arena:
🔹 Irganox 1010
Also known as Pentaerythritol tetrakis(3-(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)propionate), Irganox 1010 is often considered the gold standard in primary antioxidants. Developed by BASF, it’s widely used in polyolefins, engineering plastics, and elastomers.
🔹 Irganox 1076
A monophenolic antioxidant, Irganox 1076 is chemically known as Octadecyl 3-(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)propionate. It’s prized for its good light stability and low volatility, making it suitable for films, fibers, and packaging.
🔹 Ethanox 330
Supplied by SABO, Ethanox 330 (also called Tris(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxybenzyl)isocyanurate) is a triazine-based antioxidant with high efficiency and good thermal resistance. It’s often used in high-performance polymers and wire & cable applications.
Let’s compare them side by side:
| Parameter | Primary Antioxidant 1790 | Irganox 1010 | Irganox 1076 | Ethanox 330 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chemical Structure | Multi-ring hindered phenol | Tetrakis ester | Monophenolic ester | Triazine-linked phenol |
| Molecular Weight | ~1250 g/mol | ~1178 g/mol | ~531 g/mol | ~699 g/mol |
| Melting Point | 55–65°C | 50–70°C | 50–60°C | 180–200°C |
| Volatility (at 200°C) | Low | Very low | Moderate | Low |
| Migration Resistance | High | High | Moderate | High |
| Processing Stability | Excellent | Excellent | Good | Excellent |
| Cost (approx.) | Moderate | High | Moderate | High |
| Common Applications | Polyolefins, wires, cables, automotive | General-purpose polymers | Films, packaging, textiles | High-temp polymers, electrical insulation |
From this table alone, we can see that while all these antioxidants serve similar purposes, their individual strengths and weaknesses vary significantly depending on the application.
Performance Showdown: Real-World Testing
To understand how Primary Antioxidant 1790 stacks up, let’s look at some real-world tests conducted in various industries.
🧪 Thermal Aging Test on Polyethylene (PE)
In a study published in Polymer Degradation and Stability (2021), several antioxidants were tested in HDPE samples subjected to accelerated thermal aging at 120°C over 1000 hours. The results showed:
| Sample | % Retained Tensile Strength | Δ Color Change (ΔE) |
|---|---|---|
| Unstabilized PE | 38% | 12.5 |
| With Irganox 1010 | 82% | 3.1 |
| With Irganox 1076 | 75% | 4.8 |
| With Ethanox 330 | 85% | 2.7 |
| With Primary Antioxidant 1790 | 83% | 3.0 |
Impressive! Primary Antioxidant 1790 performed nearly as well as Ethanox 330 and slightly better than Irganox 1010 in terms of tensile retention. Color stability was also excellent, indicating strong protection against oxidative discoloration.
🛠️ Mechanical Properties in Rubber Compounds
Another test focused on natural rubber vulcanizates exposed to 100°C for 72 hours. The elongation at break was measured before and after aging:
| Antioxidant Used | Initial Elongation (%) | After Aging (%) | Retention Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | 650 | 320 | 49% |
| Irganox 1010 | 660 | 510 | 77% |
| Irganox 1076 | 655 | 490 | 75% |
| Ethanox 330 | 665 | 530 | 80% |
| Primary Antioxidant 1790 | 660 | 520 | 79% |
Again, Primary Antioxidant 1790 held its own, showing mechanical property retention comparable to Ethanox 330 and slightly better than Irganox 1010.
📉 Migration and Bloom Test in PVC Films
Migration and blooming are critical issues in flexible PVC films. In a controlled experiment, each antioxidant was incorporated at 0.5 phr and stored at 60°C for two weeks. Visual inspection and surface wipe tests were conducted:
| Antioxidant | Surface Bloom (Visual) | Wipe Test Residue |
|---|---|---|
| Irganox 1010 | Mild | Trace |
| Irganox 1076 | Noticeable | Moderate |
| Ethanox 330 | Minimal | None |
| Primary Antioxidant 1790 | Minimal | None |
Once again, Primary Antioxidant 1790 and Ethanox 330 came out on top, showing minimal signs of migration. This is likely due to their larger molecular size and higher compatibility with the PVC matrix.
Cost vs. Performance: Where Does the Sweet Spot Lie?
While performance is king, cost is always a factor. Here’s a rough breakdown based on current global pricing (as of early 2024):
| Product | Approximate Price (USD/kg) | Estimated Shelf Life | Availability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Irganox 1010 | $25–30 | 3 years | Widely available |
| Irganox 1076 | $20–25 | 2 years | Widely available |
| Ethanox 330 | $28–35 | 2.5 years | Regional availability |
| Primary Antioxidant 1790 | $18–22 | 2 years | Increasingly available |
As we can see, Primary Antioxidant 1790 offers a compelling value proposition — delivering performance close to premium products like Ethanox 330 and Irganox 1010 at a lower price point. For manufacturers looking to optimize costs without sacrificing quality, this could be a winning combination.
Environmental and Safety Considerations
With growing emphasis on sustainability and chemical safety, it’s important to consider the environmental profile of these antioxidants.
According to data from the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) and REACH registrations:
- All four antioxidants are classified as non-volatile organic compounds.
- They do not bioaccumulate easily and have low aquatic toxicity.
- Primary Antioxidant 1790 and Irganox 1010 are generally regarded as safe under normal industrial use conditions.
- Ethanox 330 has shown slight concerns in aquatic toxicity studies (see Chemosphere, 2022), though still within acceptable regulatory limits.
None of these compounds are currently listed under SVHC (Substances of Very High Concern), making them relatively green-friendly options compared to older antioxidant families like aromatic amines.
Application-Specific Recommendations
Now that we’ve seen how they perform in lab settings, let’s talk about where each antioxidant shines best.
🚗 Automotive Components
For under-the-hood applications where heat and oxidation are constant threats, Primary Antioxidant 1790 and Irganox 1010 are ideal due to their excellent thermal stability and low volatility. Both are compatible with EPDM, silicone rubbers, and PA66 systems.
🏗️ Building & Construction Materials
In roofing membranes, pipes, and insulation foams, Ethanox 330 may be preferred due to its superior performance at elevated temperatures and its ability to withstand prolonged UV exposure when combined with HALS (Hindered Amine Light Stabilizers).
🎬 Packaging and Films
For clear films and food-grade packaging, Irganox 1076 is often chosen for its clarity and low odor. However, if long-term durability is a concern, Primary Antioxidant 1790 offers a solid alternative without compromising aesthetics.
⚡ Electrical & Electronics
High-purity applications like wire coatings and connectors benefit from Irganox 1010 and Ethanox 330, both of which offer excellent dielectric properties and minimal ionic contamination.
Final Thoughts: Choosing Your Champion
Choosing the right antioxidant isn’t about picking the “best” one — it’s about finding the one that best fits your process, your material, and your end-use requirements. Each of these antioxidants brings something unique to the table:
- Irganox 1010 remains a reliable benchmark with proven performance across decades.
- Irganox 1076 is a go-to for lightweight films and packaging.
- Ethanox 330 excels in high-temperature environments and specialty polymers.
- And Primary Antioxidant 1790? It’s the rising star — offering balanced performance, low migration, and cost-efficiency.
If there’s one thing we’ve learned here, it’s that chemistry doesn’t have to be dry — it can be colorful, nuanced, and even a little bit dramatic. Like choosing between a classic novel and a modern thriller, the choice depends on what story you want your material to tell.
So next time you’re formulating a new compound or optimizing an existing one, don’t just reach for the usual suspects. Take a moment to consider what each antioxidant brings to the mix — because sometimes, the hero of your formulation is waiting quietly on the shelf, ready to step into the spotlight.
References
- Smith, J., Lee, K., & Wang, H. (2021). Comparative Study of Hindered Phenolic Antioxidants in Polyethylene Stabilization. Polymer Degradation and Stability, 189, 109582.
- Zhang, Y., Chen, M., & Kumar, R. (2020). Evaluation of Antioxidant Migration in Flexible PVC Films. Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 137(45), 49231.
- European Chemicals Agency (ECHA). (2023). REACH Registration Dossiers for Irganox 1010, Irganox 1076, and Ethanox 330.
- Li, X., Zhao, Q., & Park, S. (2022). Aquatic Toxicity Assessment of Ethanox 330 and Related Phenolic Antioxidants. Chemosphere, 291, 132876.
- BASF Technical Data Sheet. (2023). Irganox 1010 – Product Information.
- SABO Antioxidants. (2022). Ethanox 330 Technical Bulletin.
- Anonymous. (2023). Market Analysis Report on Antioxidants for Plastics. Chemical Insights Quarterly, 12(3), 45–60.
- Tang, L., Huang, Z., & Singh, A. (2019). Thermal and Oxidative Stability of Natural Rubber Vulcanizates with Various Antioxidants. Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 92(2), 215–230.
Let me know if you’d like this formatted into a downloadable Word or PDF document, or if you need additional sections like supplier profiles, regional availability, or future trends in antioxidant development.
Sales Contact：sales@newtopchem.com