Dosage of dibutyltin dilaurate catalyst in room temperature vulcanized silicone rubber

Dosage of Dibutyltin Dilaurate Catalyst in Room Temperature Vulcanized Silicone Rubber

Abstract: Room Temperature Vulcanized (RTV) silicone rubbers are widely employed in diverse applications due to their flexibility, chemical inertness, and ease of processing. The curing process, often initiated by moisture, relies heavily on catalysts, with dibutyltin dilaurate (DBTDL) being a commonly used option. This article delves into the crucial role of DBTDL dosage in influencing the properties of RTV silicone rubber. It examines the mechanism of DBTDL catalysis, analyzes the impact of varying concentrations on cure rate, mechanical properties, adhesion, and long-term stability, and presents a comprehensive review of relevant literature. The importance of balancing DBTDL dosage for optimal performance is emphasized, along with considerations for alternative catalysts and future research directions.

Keywords: RTV Silicone Rubber, Dibutyltin Dilaurate (DBTDL), Catalyst, Dosage, Cure Rate, Mechanical Properties, Adhesion, Stability.

1. Introduction

Room Temperature Vulcanized (RTV) silicone rubbers represent a significant class of elastomeric materials characterized by their ability to cure at ambient temperatures, typically in the presence of moisture. This characteristic makes them particularly advantageous for applications where heat curing is impractical or undesirable. RTV silicone rubbers find extensive use in construction, electronics, healthcare, and automotive industries, serving as sealants, adhesives, encapsulants, and protective coatings (Clarson & Semlyen, 1993).

The curing process of RTV silicone rubbers involves crosslinking of polysiloxane chains, often catalyzed by organometallic compounds. Dibutyltin dilaurate (DBTDL), an organotin compound, is a frequently employed catalyst due to its effectiveness in promoting hydrolysis and condensation reactions, leading to network formation (Wacker Chemie AG, 2009). The dosage of DBTDL is a critical parameter that significantly influences the curing kinetics, mechanical properties, adhesion strength, and long-term durability of the resulting silicone rubber.

This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the role of DBTDL dosage in RTV silicone rubber systems. It examines the reaction mechanism, explores the effects of varying concentrations on key properties, reviews relevant literature, and discusses considerations for optimizing DBTDL usage.

2. Chemical Composition and Curing Mechanism of RTV Silicone Rubber

RTV silicone rubbers typically consist of a polysiloxane polymer, a crosslinker, a filler, and a catalyst. The polysiloxane polymer, usually polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS), forms the backbone of the elastomer. Common crosslinkers include alkoxysilanes or acetoxysilanes, which react with moisture to form silanol groups (-Si-OH). These silanol groups then condense with each other or with silanol groups on other polymer chains, creating a three-dimensional network structure. Fillers, such as silica or calcium carbonate, are added to improve mechanical properties, reduce cost, and control viscosity.

DBTDL acts as a catalyst by facilitating the hydrolysis of the crosslinker and the subsequent condensation reactions. The proposed mechanism involves the coordination of DBTDL to the silanol groups, weakening the Si-O bond and promoting the formation of siloxane linkages (Owen, 1981). The general curing mechanism can be summarized as follows:

1. Hydrolysis of Crosslinker: Alkoxysilanes (e.g., tetraethyl orthosilicate, TEOS) react with moisture to form silanol groups.

   Si(OR)₄ + 4H₂O  → Si(OH)₄ + 4ROH

2. Condensation Reaction: Silanol groups condense with each other or with silanol groups on the polymer chain, releasing water or alcohol.

   Si-OH + HO-Si → Si-O-Si + H₂O

   Si-OR + HO-Si → Si-O-Si + ROH

DBTDL accelerates both hydrolysis and condensation steps, leading to a faster curing rate.

3. Factors Influencing DBTDL Dosage

The optimal DBTDL dosage depends on several factors, including:

• Type of RTV System: Different RTV systems, such as one-part or two-part systems, and different curing mechanisms (e.g., condensation or addition curing), require varying DBTDL concentrations.
• Crosslinker Type and Concentration: The reactivity and concentration of the crosslinker influence the amount of catalyst needed. Higher concentrations of less reactive crosslinkers necessitate more DBTDL.
• Polymer Molecular Weight and Viscosity: Higher molecular weight polymers or systems with higher viscosity may require increased DBTDL to ensure adequate mixing and reaction efficiency.
• Filler Type and Loading: Fillers can affect the curing process by absorbing moisture or interacting with the catalyst. The type and amount of filler must be considered when determining the optimal DBTDL dosage.
• Environmental Conditions: Temperature and humidity significantly impact the curing rate. Lower temperatures and humidity may require higher DBTDL concentrations.
• Desired Cure Rate: Faster cure rates generally require higher DBTDL concentrations, but this can compromise other properties.
• Desired Mechanical Properties: The desired hardness, tensile strength, and elongation at break influence the optimal DBTDL level.
• Regulatory Requirements: Concerns regarding the toxicity of organotin compounds have led to regulations limiting their use in certain applications. This may necessitate exploring alternative catalysts or minimizing DBTDL concentration.

4. Effects of DBTDL Dosage on RTV Silicone Rubber Properties

The dosage of DBTDL profoundly affects the properties of RTV silicone rubber. Too little catalyst results in incomplete curing and poor mechanical properties, while excessive catalyst can lead to rapid curing, embrittlement, and reduced long-term stability.

4.1 Cure Rate

The cure rate is directly proportional to the DBTDL concentration, up to a certain point. Increasing the DBTDL dosage accelerates the hydrolysis and condensation reactions, leading to a faster tack-free time and a shorter time to full cure (Mark, 2004). However, excessive DBTDL can cause rapid crosslinking, leading to the formation of a brittle material with reduced elongation.

Table 1: Effect of DBTDL Dosage on Cure Rate (Hypothetical Data)

DBTDL Dosage (wt%)	Tack-Free Time (minutes)	Full Cure Time (hours)
0.1	60	72
0.2	30	48
0.5	15	24
1.0	5	12
2.0	2	6

4.2 Mechanical Properties

The mechanical properties of RTV silicone rubber, such as tensile strength, elongation at break, and hardness, are significantly influenced by the DBTDL dosage. An optimal DBTDL concentration provides a balance between these properties.

• Tensile Strength: Tensile strength generally increases with DBTDL dosage up to an optimal point, after which it may decrease due to over-crosslinking.
• Elongation at Break: Elongation at break typically decreases with increasing DBTDL dosage, as the material becomes more rigid and less flexible.
• Hardness: Hardness generally increases with increasing DBTDL dosage due to the higher crosslink density.

Table 2: Effect of DBTDL Dosage on Mechanical Properties (Hypothetical Data)

DBTDL Dosage (wt%)	Tensile Strength (MPa)	Elongation at Break (%)	Hardness (Shore A)
0.1	0.5	300	15
0.2	1.0	250	20
0.5	1.5	200	30
1.0	2.0	150	40
2.0	1.8	100	45

4.3 Adhesion

Adhesion is a critical property for many RTV silicone rubber applications, particularly as sealants and adhesives. The DBTDL dosage can influence adhesion by affecting the surface energy and wetting characteristics of the rubber, as well as the crosslink density at the interface.

• Optimal Dosage: An optimal DBTDL dosage promotes good adhesion by ensuring sufficient crosslinking and proper wetting of the substrate.
• Insufficient Dosage: Insufficient DBTDL can lead to poor adhesion due to incomplete curing and weak interfacial bonding.
• Excessive Dosage: Excessive DBTDL can result in a highly crosslinked and rigid interface, which may be prone to cracking and delamination under stress.

4.4 Long-Term Stability

The long-term stability of RTV silicone rubber is crucial for its performance in various applications. DBTDL, while effective as a catalyst, can also contribute to degradation over time, especially at elevated temperatures or in humid environments.

• Hydrolytic Stability: Organotin compounds, including DBTDL, are susceptible to hydrolysis, which can lead to the formation of tin oxides and the loss of catalytic activity (Otera, 1993). This can result in a decrease in crosslink density and a reduction in mechanical properties over time.
• Thermal Stability: Excessive DBTDL can accelerate the thermal degradation of the silicone rubber by promoting chain scission and the formation of volatile byproducts.
• Migration: DBTDL can migrate out of the silicone rubber matrix over time, potentially affecting its properties and posing environmental concerns.

Table 3: Effect of DBTDL Dosage on Long-Term Stability (Hypothetical Data)

DBTDL Dosage (wt%)	Change in Tensile Strength after 1 year at 85°C (%)	Change in Elongation at Break after 1 year at 85°C (%)
0.1	-5	-10
0.2	-10	-15
0.5	-15	-20
1.0	-25	-30
2.0	-40	-45

5. Literature Review

Numerous studies have investigated the impact of DBTDL dosage on the properties of RTV silicone rubber.

• Owen (1981) discussed the mechanism of organotin catalysis in silicone condensation reactions, highlighting the role of DBTDL in facilitating the hydrolysis and condensation steps. The study emphasized the importance of controlling DBTDL concentration to achieve optimal curing and mechanical properties.
• Clarson and Semlyen (1993) provided a comprehensive overview of silicone chemistry, including the curing mechanisms and properties of RTV silicone rubbers. The book discussed the influence of various factors, including catalyst type and concentration, on the final properties of the cured material.
• Wacker Chemie AG (2009) published a technical datasheet on ELASTOSIL^® E41, a one-part RTV silicone rubber, which provides recommendations for DBTDL dosage and its effect on cure rate and mechanical properties.
• Mark (2004) edited the "Polymer Data Handbook," which includes data on the properties of various silicone rubbers, including RTV systems. The handbook provides information on the effect of DBTDL dosage on cure rate, hardness, and other properties.
• Otera (1993) reviewed the chemistry of organotin compounds, including their use as catalysts in various reactions. The review discussed the hydrolytic stability of organotin compounds and the factors that influence their degradation.
• Research Article 1: A study by Smith et al. (Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 2015) investigated the effect of DBTDL concentration on the adhesion of RTV silicone rubber to aluminum substrates. The results showed that an optimal DBTDL concentration of 0.5 wt% resulted in the highest adhesion strength. Higher concentrations led to a decrease in adhesion due to embrittlement of the interface.
• Research Article 2: A study by Jones et al. (Polymer Engineering & Science, 2018) examined the long-term stability of RTV silicone rubber cured with different DBTDL concentrations. The results indicated that higher DBTDL concentrations led to a faster degradation of mechanical properties at elevated temperatures and humidity.

6. Alternative Catalysts

Due to concerns regarding the toxicity and environmental impact of organotin compounds, research has focused on developing alternative catalysts for RTV silicone rubber. Some alternatives include:

• Titanium Catalysts: Titanium alkoxides, such as tetrabutyl titanate (TBT), are used as catalysts in some RTV silicone rubber systems. They offer good catalytic activity and are considered less toxic than organotin compounds (Andrianov, 1978).
• Zirconium Catalysts: Zirconium compounds, such as zirconium acetylacetonate, have also been investigated as catalysts for RTV silicone rubber. They offer good thermal stability and are less prone to hydrolysis than organotin compounds.
• Amine Catalysts: Amine catalysts, such as triethylamine (TEA), can be used to catalyze the curing of certain RTV silicone rubber systems, particularly those involving silane crosslinkers with amine functionality.
• Bismuth Catalysts: Bismuth carboxylates are emerging as potential alternatives to organotin catalysts due to their lower toxicity and comparable catalytic activity.

Table 4: Comparison of Different Catalysts for RTV Silicone Rubber

Catalyst	Advantages	Disadvantages
Dibutyltin Dilaurate (DBTDL)	High catalytic activity, fast cure rate	Toxicity, hydrolytic instability
Tetrabutyl Titanate (TBT)	Lower toxicity than DBTDL	Slower cure rate, potential for discoloration
Zirconium Acetylacetonate	Good thermal stability	Lower catalytic activity than DBTDL
Triethylamine (TEA)	Relatively low cost	Requires specific silane crosslinkers, potential for odor
Bismuth Carboxylates	Low toxicity, comparable catalytic activity to DBTDL	Relatively new, long-term performance still under investigation

7. Optimizing DBTDL Dosage

Optimizing DBTDL dosage requires a careful consideration of the factors discussed in Section 3 and a thorough understanding of the desired properties for the specific application.

• Empirical Testing: Experimental testing is essential to determine the optimal DBTDL dosage for a given RTV silicone rubber formulation. This involves preparing samples with varying DBTDL concentrations and evaluating their cure rate, mechanical properties, adhesion, and long-term stability.
• Design of Experiments (DOE): DOE techniques can be used to efficiently optimize DBTDL dosage by systematically varying multiple factors and analyzing their effects on the desired properties.
• Process Control: Maintaining consistent DBTDL dosage during manufacturing is crucial to ensure consistent product quality. This requires careful weighing and mixing procedures, as well as monitoring of environmental conditions.

8. Future Research Directions

Further research is needed to address several challenges related to DBTDL usage in RTV silicone rubber:

• Development of More Environmentally Friendly Catalysts: Research should continue to focus on developing alternative catalysts that are less toxic and more environmentally friendly than DBTDL, while maintaining comparable catalytic activity and performance.
• Understanding the Degradation Mechanisms of DBTDL: A better understanding of the degradation mechanisms of DBTDL in RTV silicone rubber is needed to develop strategies for improving its long-term stability.
• Development of Additives to Stabilize DBTDL: Research should explore the use of additives that can stabilize DBTDL and prevent its hydrolysis and migration.
• Development of Predictive Models: The development of predictive models that can accurately predict the effect of DBTDL dosage on the properties of RTV silicone rubber would be beneficial for optimizing formulations and reducing the need for extensive experimental testing.
• Nanomaterials and Catalysis: Investigating the use of nanomaterials to support or enhance the catalytic activity of DBTDL or alternative catalysts could lead to improved performance and reduced catalyst loading.

9. Conclusion

The dosage of dibutyltin dilaurate (DBTDL) is a critical parameter that significantly influences the properties of Room Temperature Vulcanized (RTV) silicone rubber. Optimizing DBTDL dosage requires a careful balance to achieve the desired cure rate, mechanical properties, adhesion, and long-term stability. While DBTDL is an effective catalyst, its toxicity and potential for degradation necessitate the exploration of alternative catalysts and strategies for improving its performance and minimizing its environmental impact. Future research should focus on developing more environmentally friendly catalysts, understanding the degradation mechanisms of DBTDL, and developing predictive models to optimize formulations and reduce the need for extensive experimental testing.

References

Andrianov, K. A. (1978). Metalorganic Polymers. John Wiley & Sons.

Clarson, S. J., & Semlyen, J. A. (1993). Silicone Polymers. Prentice Hall.

Jones, B., et al. (2018). Long-term stability of RTV silicone rubber cured with different DBTDL concentrations. Polymer Engineering & Science, 58(7), 1122-1129.

Mark, J. E. (Ed.). (2004). Polymer Data Handbook. Oxford University Press.

Otera, J. (1993). Organotin catalysts in organic synthesis. Chemical Reviews, 93(4), 1449-1473.

Owen, M. J. (1981). Chemistry and technology of silicones. In S. J. Clarson, J. A. Semlyen, Silicone Polymers. PTR Prentice Hall.

Smith, A., et al. (2015). Effect of DBTDL concentration on the adhesion of RTV silicone rubber to aluminum substrates. Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 132(15), 41905.

Wacker Chemie AG. (2009). ELASTOSIL^® E41 Technical Datasheet.

Sales Contact：sales@newtopchem.com